When Andrew Thale arrives at his great-aunt Harriet’s abandoned property in rural Massachusetts, he expects nothing more than a quick assessment for his father’s company. What he discovers instead is a house full of eccentric squatters, buried treasure, witchcraft, and the most unexpected gift of all—healing and renewal.
A Synopsis That Barely Scratches the Surface
Dorothy Gilman’s Thale’s Folly (1999) follows Andrew Thale, a blocked writer suffering from PTSD after surviving a plane crash. Forced by his corporate vice president father to inspect the family’s neglected property, Andrew encounters four charming inhabitants who have been secretly living there since his great-aunt’s death five years earlier.
The household consists of Gussie, an herb gardener with magical abilities; Miss L’Hommedieu, an enigmatic woman with a mysterious African past; Leo, a Marxist anarchist who listens to news on battery-powered radio; and the beautiful nineteen-year-old Tarragon, who was found abandoned and named after the herb. Together, they’ve created an unconventional family surviving off the land, cooking by kerosene lamp, and planting potatoes by the dark of the moon.
When Andrew’s car breaks down and he’s stranded for several days, his cynical worldview begins to crack. Through midnight raids on the town dump, philosophical discussions over sparse meals, watching sunsets from the porch, and climbing Bald Hill under the stars, Andrew finds himself drawn into their world of simplicity, authenticity, and unexpected magic.
The plot thickens when the property’s rightful inheritance is questioned, setting off a treasure hunt guided by cryptic clues in Aunt Harriet’s will. But the real treasure Andrew finds isn’t buried under Tarragon plants—it’s the rediscovery of his own creativity, purpose, and capacity to feel again. Miss L’Hommedieu’s mysterious past in Africa, revealed only after her death, provides Andrew with the ultimate gift: a story that reignites his passion for writing and pulls him from the darkness of trauma.
Genre and Literary Merit
Thale’s Folly defies easy categorization, blending elements of contemporary fiction, magical realism, mystery, and gentle romance. Gilman, best known for her beloved Mrs. Pollifax spy series, demonstrates her versatility with this standalone novel that feels part fairy tale, part treasure hunt, and part meditation on healing.
The book occupies a sweet spot between cozy mystery and literary fiction. While there’s a treasure to uncover and secrets to reveal, the true mystery is how broken people can heal one another. Gilman’s prose is deceptively simple—conversational and accessible—yet layered with philosophical depth and subtle observations about modern life versus simpler living.
What elevates Thale’s Folly beyond typical genre fiction is Gilman’s ability to create characters who feel simultaneously quirky and utterly real. Miss L’Hommedieu quotes Anatole France while living without electricity. Leo debates global capitalism while raiding dumps for kerosene heaters. These contradictions make them human rather than caricatures.
Themes That Resonate Across Decades
Healing from Trauma: Andrew’s journey from depression and creative paralysis to renewal forms the emotional core. Gilman handles PTSD with sensitivity unusual for 1999, showing how healing isn’t linear and often comes from unexpected sources.
Simple Living vs. Modern Life: The household at Thale’s Folly lives without electricity, refrigeration, or running water—not from poverty but from choice and circumstance. Gilman doesn’t romanticize poverty but does question whether our modern conveniences truly make us happier.
Found Family: The squatters have created a family bound not by blood but by mutual need and acceptance. Each person was unwanted somewhere else, making their chosen family all the more precious.
Magic in the Mundane: Gussy’s “witchcraft” is really just deep knowledge of herbs, moon cycles, and natural rhythms. Yet Gilman leaves room for genuine mystery—does magic exist, or do we simply call it that when we don’t understand nature’s workings?
The Power of Story: Miss L’Hommedieu writes only beginnings and sometimes endings, never middles. This becomes a metaphor for Andrew’s creative block and ultimate breakthrough. Stories have power—to heal, to reveal truth, to connect us across time and space.
Second Chances: Nearly every character gets one—Andrew’s parents reunite, the squatters inherit wealth, Andrew rediscovers his purpose. Gilman’s worldview is fundamentally hopeful without being saccharine.
Reading vs. Listening: Three Distinct Experiences
Having enjoyed this story through audiobook narration, I find myself contemplating the three primary ways modern readers experience fiction: traditional print, professional narration, and digital text-to-speech services. Each offers something unique.
The Paperback Experience
Reading Thale’s Folly in paperback would offer the tactile pleasure of turning pages while sitting in a garden or on a porch—mirroring the book’s own celebration of simple pleasures. You control the pace completely, perhaps lingering over Miss L’Hommedieu’s cryptic pronouncements or racing through the midnight dump raid. You can flip back to catch details about Aunt Harriet’s will or study the gradual revelation of Miss L’Hommedieu’s African past.
The physical book allows for marginalia, dog-eared pages, and the ability to immediately reread passages that strike you. There’s something appropriate about reading a book that celebrates analog living in its most analog format.
Professional Voice Acting: An Immersive Performance
John McDonough’s narration of Thale’s Folly transforms the reading experience into something closer to theater. His performance captures Leo’s gruff anarchism, Miss L’Hommedieu’s aristocratic eccentricity, Tarragon’s youthful earnestness, and Andrew’s gradual transformation from cynical to engaged.
Professional narrators make choices about emphasis, pacing, and character voices that add interpretation to the text. McDonough’s handling of the climactic scene where Andrew discovers Miss L’Hommedieu’s African past—with its revelations about murder, conspiracy, and unanswered questions—adds dramatic weight through vocal performance.
The audiobook format suits certain reading contexts perfectly: commutes, household chores, walks in nature. Ironically, listening to Thale’s Folly while doing manual tasks like gardening or cooking feels appropriate to the book’s themes. The narrator becomes a storyteller in the oral tradition, and you become part of an audience rather than a solitary reader.
However, audiobooks demand linear consumption. You can’t easily skim, and referring back to earlier details requires awkward rewinding. Complex plots with multiple timelines or extensive characters lists can become harder to track.
Digital Voice Services: The Democratization of Audiobooks
Today’s AI-powered text-to-speech services offer unprecedented accessibility. Natural-sounding voices can now read virtually any text aloud, making audiobooks available for titles that might never receive professional narration. For readers with visual impairments or reading difficulties, these services are transformative.
The trade-off is in artistry. While modern digital voices have improved dramatically, they still lack the interpretive depth of skilled narrators like McDonough. An AI voice can pronounce “Miss L’Hommedieu” correctly with proper programming, but it won’t capture the layered emotions when Andrew discovers her trunk containing evidence of a decades-old African murder mystery.
Digital voices read Miss L’Hommedieu’s fragmented story beginnings with the same inflection as Andrew’s internal monologue. They don’t yet understand when to pause for dramatic effect or how to shade a character’s dialogue with subtext. The midnight dump raid—a scene that should crackle with absurdist humor—becomes flatter without human interpretation.
Yet for many readers, some narration beats no narration. The convenience of having your e-reader or phone read aloud any book in your library, adjusting speed and voice to preference, offers flexibility that neither paperbacks nor traditional audiobooks can match.
The Verdict: Choose Based on Your Reading Life
For Thale’s Folly specifically, I’d recommend:
Choose paperback if: You want to savor Gilman’s prose at your own pace, enjoy the freedom to flip back to earlier clues about the treasure, and appreciate the irony of reading about off-grid living while unplugged yourself.
Choose professional audiobook if: You want the full theatrical experience of John McDonough’s interpretation, prefer consuming books during activities like driving or exercise, and trust a skilled narrator to enhance the story through performance.
Choose digital narration if: You need accessibility features, want the flexibility to switch between reading and listening seamlessly, or are exploring Gilman’s work and want to try multiple titles quickly.
Personally, having experienced it through professional narration, I’m now curious to read the physical book to catch details I might have missed and to experience Gilman’s prose on the page. The best books reward multiple formats and repeated readings.
Final Thoughts
Thale’s Folly is Dorothy Gilman at her finest—whimsical yet grounded, mysterious yet clear-eyed, hopeful yet honest about life’s difficulties. It’s a book about treasure that understands the real treasures are connection, purpose, and the courage to begin again.
Whether you encounter it in paperback, through John McDonough’s warm narration, or via digital voice, you’ll find a story that reminds us that sometimes the greatest adventures happen when our carefully planned lives break down on an abandoned road, forcing us to discover what we didn’t know we were seeking.
In an age of increasing digital complexity, there’s something deeply satisfying about a story where people thrive without internet, survive on foraged fish and garden vegetables, and find renewal not through therapy apps but through watching sunsets and climbing hills under the stars. Gilman understood that healing often requires stepping away from the noise—a message that resonates even more strongly today than when she wrote it.
Rating: 4.5/5 stars – A gentle, wise, and thoroughly enchanting novel that deserves to be rediscovered by new generations of readers.
A Note from our Editor
Thank you to the Silver Dagger Book Tours for their Contribution to our online Magazine Today! WBW will be participating in a number of their book tours over the coming months. We would encourage any North Florida Writers who would like to Guest Post on this site or be a featured author on the North Florida Writers Tour website then please get in touch using our CONTACT US form. Our site has an excellent monthly Newsletter that contains exclusive content. Join in on the fun! CLICK HERE!
If you found our article helpful, we hope you will consider contributing to our coffee fund to keep us up and running creating more helpful blogs now and in the future!
